
Tupac Shakur’s holographic resurrection at this weekend’s Coachella was a real mind-bender. Whether you found it inspiring or tasteless, it’s quickly become a philosophical conundrum with some pretty heavy implications: What would real-life Tupac think of the performance? His mom endorsed it, but who ultimately can speak for the dead?
The question became even more potent when the Wall Street Journal reported that, given the success of the hologram at Coachella, Dr. Dre and Snoop are considering taking Tupac out with them on a full tour.
Watching a hologram perform feels a lot like the real thing. Audiences buying tickets for a Snoop-Dre-Tupac tour would be buying them almost as an equal billing—Tupac’s presence would surely be a draw for ticket sales. Which brings up a whole other question: How should the artist—or the artist’s estate—get paid for the shows?
Billboard spoke with entertainment lawyer Donald Passman, who knows so much about the music business he wrote a book called “All You Need to Know About the Music Business.” According to Passman, the hologram live show presentes an unprecedented issue:
How much would it cost to use Tupac’s likeness for two songs at a Coachella performance? “Boy, I have no idea,” says Passman. “I guess if I represented him I would want a good sized fee for it because it’s an element of the show. And I could go anywhere from what I would charge as a live artist to show up as a guest down to what I would charge to do a lighting design.” But he admits arriving at a fee wouldn’t be easy. “There’s no precedent for it.”
It’s a grey area. It’s actually not even a real hologram—it’s a two dimensional image projected on an invisible screen that the real-life rappers stand behind. For an in-depth look at how it works check out this WSJ article. But the point is, it’s an attraction and a revenue driver.
Illustrating this point, a spoof flyer made the rounds on the internet this week imagining an all-hologram Coachella lineup in the future, headlined by Michael Jackson and The Clash. It’s not that hard to imagine full sets from hologram heroes in the not so distant future. The question of how the headliners will get paid, and how much, is brand new. And it’s is a brand new revenue stream in a business that has seen all its revenue streams decline steadily over the last decade.
At any rate, we can look forward to another performance from Hologram Tupac at this weekend’s Coachella Part 2.





April 20, 2012 at 1:47 pm, Robert Hill said:
Ain't that bout a bitch, and the living are in some sort of SUPPOSED recession. Smfh
April 23, 2012 at 6:58 pm, Kyle Daley said:
yeaaaa
April 23, 2012 at 7:28 pm, Matthew Jonathan Cote said:
Dre and Snoop are punks. No talk of violence in hip hop, no talk of revolution, no talk of culture: just money. It was a nifty trick, but seriously, step up your game and find LIVING talent, dudes.
April 23, 2012 at 8:11 pm, Jon Shoer said:
the fact that he can be re-created into a hologram and ppl will go crazy just goes to show how NOT-amazing he is/was. I saw that shit over the weekend and it was cool but after seeing Radiohead's performance, among many others, these artist could never be replicated into holograms, they are just too good/unique/real/talented, shit that could never be just streamed onto a stage.
April 23, 2012 at 8:31 pm, Hernan Mendez said:
Really? You're saying tupac isn't amazing cause they could replicate him into a hologram? Tupac will have more of an effect/impact on people cause of his TALENT, than radio head, whoever they are.
April 23, 2012 at 8:42 pm, Matthew Jonathan Cote said:
Hernan Mendez Yeah, I couldn't devalue tupac simply based on the fact that his technologically embodied presence got a reaction from the crowd. In my opinion, tupac would have talked SOOOO much shit about the current industry, he'd be Malcom X by now – probably would have stopped rapping in order to truly squash thug life. ANY artists can be replicated, but the why should be held beneath the microscope of scrutiny. If you want art, pull away the lighting, the pyrotechnics, the antics, the bullshit – and have a group of people playing music. Tell me that would get the same reaction. It isn't about art – it's entertainment. Whatever entertains will prevail until the crowds demand something with greater substance. Tupac was a creator of art, the entertainment industry abused his image, threw him in prison, then killed him; I highly doubt that much effort will be put forth to overturn RadioHead. They are musicians, but they'll never inspire a revolution.
April 23, 2012 at 8:46 pm, Hernan Mendez said:
Exactly. I agree with what you're saying. As a die hard tupac fan I was disgusted that he was on stage with snoop and dre.
April 23, 2012 at 8:51 pm, Jon Shoer said:
I'm not saying tupac wasn't talented in the fact of his lyrics and music. he absolutely was revolutionary with his music. performance wise… projecting an image onto a stage for 60,000 ppl is bullshit and that relates to his skills as a "performer", not an artist. As far as entertainment goes, its bullshit.
Radiohead… whoever they are??… one of the best bands that has been around for 20 years not only making complex and deep amazing music, but a group of guys that can perform so well that a hologram could never ever even be an option. They perform. They owned Coachella this weekend based on their performance, not a projected image of a guy rapping, it was bullshit.
April 23, 2012 at 10:03 pm, Matthew Jonathan Cote said:
I think the tupac hologram says more about Snoop And Dre than Tupac. Does the energy of Radiohead perch upon your consciousness like a baseball cap of lead? Do they inspire you to change, to modify – improve or inspire? Have they offered elation of body AS WELL AS the emancipation of mind? If so, then long live radio head. If not, then they can be replicated. They will be replicated. They are a replication. All art is mimicry, all creation is a catastrophe repackaged
April 29, 2012 at 5:46 pm, Thulani Xulu said:
that the dopest thing I ever heard.i'll like to see tupac in hologram performing with snoop.
August 21, 2012 at 8:19 pm, Tupac's Hologram May Go On Tour said:
[...] more on the new hologram revenue stream, check out Alex Moore’s article. Tags: 2pac, [...]