
Last year Target was at the front lines of a controversial trend that’s seen retail chains opening earlier and earlier for Black Friday and encroaching on workers’ holidays nationwide. After starting the Black Friday extravaganza at 4am in recent years, last year Target joined Walmart, Best Buy and others in opening at midnight for the first time against the wishes of a flurry of petitions that cropped up from employees online, gathering hundreds of thousands of signatures.
This year Black Friday creeps further into Thanksgiving itself as Target and Walmart will both open at 9pm on Thanksgiving night. Again a blizzard of petitions have popped up from employees asking the companies to please allow them to have Thanksgiving with their families. An especially articulate one aimed at Target with over 200,000 signatures argues: “I’m not complaining about being a minimum wage worker. Target, as a company, does some good and maintains a commitment to charity. Thanksgiving, though, is one of the three days retail workers get off a year, a day most spend with family. …Since workers need to show up sometimes hours before the story officially opens, this will take much of Thanksgiving away from retail employees across the country. Target can take the high road and save Thanksgiving for employees like me and our families by saying no to ‘Thanksgiving Creep.’”
Holidays and elections tend to make stories like this headline-worthy. Papa John’s is getting its share of heat right now for insisting it’ll cut employees’ hours rather than raise the price of pizza 3 cents in order to give them healthcare as will be required under Obamacare for employees working over 30 hours a week. But large corporations tend to do this kind of thing all year, whether or not it makes national headlines.
As corporations fight tooth and nail for every dollar of profit in a still-terrible economy, the issue of unionization seems more important than ever. If corporations won’t prioritize taking care of workers, even fighting the federal government in its efforts to foce them to, is it time for workers to start insisting on taking better care of themselves?
When Target workers in Valley Stream, NY voted against unionizing in May, a judge found that Target had engaged in widespread intimidation to keep them from voting for unionization: They “barred employees from wearing union buttons and distributing fliers, had improperly threatened to discipline employees who discussed union matters and had unlawfully threatened to close the store if the workers voted to unionize.” After the judge’s ruling in May, Target did in fact close the store. For “remodeling,” they say. For over six months.
Aside from sketchy donations to anti-gay organizations, Target has a well-worn history of treating its workers like garbage. We’re not exactly a culture of regulations and good corporate governance. If workers don’t take better care of themselves, no one will. The “Save Thanksgiving” petitions are great—you should sign one—but petitions are probably not going to make Target give Thanksgiving back to its employees any more than bad media coverage will force Papa John’s to give its employees healthcare. More than ever, the idea of unionization has a healthy role to play, be it intra-organization or on the big scale of traditional unions. If Target employees want Thanksgiving back, they should think about mobilizing, fast.





November 14, 2012 at 8:43 pm, Nick Fuhrmann said:
Though I agree with the idea that employees should work that early on Thanksgiving, they do get extra pay for working on a holiday. Also, they do sign a contract saying they'll work whenever they claim they're available and on specific days they understand they HAVE to work. For disclosure, I am a former employee and my mother, who believes opening at 9 is foolish, is currently a store manager. I do disagree that we need unions. Unions suck.
November 14, 2012 at 8:51 pm, Nick Fuhrmann said:
One more thing, Target donates to many different causes. Some we may or may not like. They hold job fairs for minorities, and also have job fairs that cater exclusively to LGBT members of the working community. So don't say they make sketchy donations. That's pretty lazy of you to not do your research.
November 14, 2012 at 11:24 pm, Laura Chandler said:
They are referring to the money given to fund anti LGBT legislation. Do YOUR research please, young man. And unions don't suck. Why do you feel they do? Have you ever been a union member? Why are you under this impression?
November 15, 2012 at 9:32 pm, Nick Fuhrmann said:
It was not money given to fund anti-LGBT legislation, it was money given to a specific candidate or Super-Pac who retains interests independent to the one cause that an entity would have, but still has interests in the issue that Target finds most dire, which is a free…er market, less taxes, and regulation. I am pro-life, but I support Gary Johnson (or did), and he is not pro-life. That does not mean I support all his interests or beliefs (most I do). They are independent to the reason(s) I voted for him. So yeah. Also, Target gives money to candidates on both sides of the aisle. It is a matter of policy that they do this, and smart business sense. I could go on. And you are right to question my feelings about unions because I did not reason publicly why I dislike them. If you like, you could message me on FB and I'll explain them there, as I can be quite long-winded on the keyboard and in person. Like just now.
November 14, 2012 at 10:20 pm, OMG Tax said:
Retail workers deserve Thanksgiving off too! Sign the Petition.
November 14, 2012 at 8:00 pm, Black Friday Deals Beginning Early—On Thanksgiving Day – Patch.com | 2012-thanksgiving-sale-deal.com said:
[...] Thanksgiving Day. Walmart, Toys R' Us, Target and Best Buy are planning all-out holiday …Target's 'Save Thanksgiving' petitions: the case for unionizingDeath and TaxesWalmart, Target, Best Buy Black Friday Tablet, Laptop, HDTV DealsBooks & [...]
November 15, 2012 at 2:16 am, Tom Burl Walsh said:
Shop local. Spend your money with your neighbors. Forget Target, Walmart and all the ones like them.
November 15, 2012 at 9:42 pm, Nick Fuhrmann said:
I'd like to add, I have urged many I know to sign the petition, and to visit and voice their concerns directly to management at our local Target stores about being open. My mother has spoken to her bosses about the unpopularity of this thing, as well. I would urge all of you to do the same. We don't need unions to force retailers to do anything. WE are the economy, and we can show them that we won't support this by boycotting the Thanksgiving opening or not shopping at Target altogether. We do not need the government to point a gun towards business, at the behest of unions or any other entity's interest, and force them to do anything they don't want to; the same way you wouldn't want the government coming in your home to enforce any ideals they have that you don't. Give freedom, expect freedom. Let people and businesses live free from government interference as long as all do no monetary or physical harm. Life, liberty, property.
November 15, 2012 at 10:04 pm, Laura Chandler said:
What about the rights of the employees to unionize? Isn't that part of liberty? The government does not intervene for unions, that is not how unions work. The employees themselves intervene on their own behalf in unions. They use their collective power as the workforce to advocate fora balance f what is best for the company and best for the employees of that company. I've been in a union that voted to give themselves a paycut rather than cut the workforce, and when things turned around, the former pay was reinstated. This helped the company thrive through bad times.
There are laws that don't allow employers to punish their unions for attempting to organize, just as there are laws that keep them from discrimination, hiring underage or illegal workers, or not paying minimum wage. While you have every right to not desire a union yourself, you cannot and should not speak to the ideas and feeling of the other Target workers, many whom have expressed the desire for a union. You may not feel they need one, but perhaps they do? I understand from what you are stating you are a Libertarian and therefore your personal politics dictate being anti-union, but that in and of itself doesn't make unions bad or unneeded.
November 16, 2012 at 12:02 am, Nick Fuhrmann said:
Actually, the government does intervene. If a workforce decides to unionize, the place of business MUST allow them to despite not wanting if a majority agrees. The government imposes rules for unions, and if a business chooses to not agree with the unionization, they are under threat of being closed or fined, at the point of a gun, by the government. People may unionize all they want and no one can stop them, but that does not mean a business should have to tolerate it if they choose. If one wants to work at a union-friendly business, they themselves can find one suitable to their needs. Just because a majority of non-owners wills unionization doesn't mean it must be so. If a group of 51% votes for something, what about the rights of the 49% who voted against? And these people are hired hands, not stake-holders; so why do they get to determine how a business should correspond with its employees? I hope I'm not sounding belligerent, just trying to fit a lot of thought into one paragraph.
November 16, 2012 at 12:05 am, Laura Chandler said:
You are incorrect on several statements, bu this is just leading to pointless debate.
November 19, 2012 at 1:00 pm, Walmart workers plan 1,000 Black Friday protests | Death and Taxes said:
[...] Black Friday protests By Alex Moore 1 min agoWalmart and Target have been making news this year for stealing Thanksgiving from their employees, rolling back the opening bell on Black Friday to 9pm Thursday for the first [...]
December 17, 2012 at 4:09 pm, America’s highest-paid cop earns $484,000 | Death and Taxes said:
[...] know where some of those California budget shortfalls are coming from. Death and Taxes tends to be pro-union—it seems like the cases of people getting undue reward through union membership are far [...]