Two Harvard Law students recently filed suit against the Transportation Security Agency for their use of intrusive full-body scanners and enhanced pat down techniques. Go Crimson!
Jeffrey H. Redfern and Anant N. Pradhan, both second year Law School students, argue that full-body scanners, which take pictures of the naked body, and enhanced pat-down techniques, which require touching of the genital areas, are unconstitutional and violate the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable search and seizure, according to the suit filed on Nov. 29 at a U.S. District Court in Boston.
On separate trips out of Boston Logan Airport, Redfern and Pradhan both opted out of the full body scan and felt the enhanced pat down was “highly intrusive.”
In a recent interview with the Harvard Law Record, Pradhan said a TSA agent put his fingers inside the waistband of his pants, lifted his buttocks, and felt his groin. “They’ll go all the way up until—well, they go all the way up,” he told the Record.
Pradhan and Redfern argue that the enhanced pat down, “if done non-consensually, would amount to a sexual assault in most jurisdictions,” and should not be used without reasonable suspicion and probable cause.
The TSA has recently seen a deluge of negative media surrounding the full body scanner and pat down techniques. Last month, John Tyner sparked the flame when he refused to go through the body scanner. When Tyner told the TSA agent preparing to give him a pat down, “If you touch my junk, I am going to have you arrested,” he was fined $11,000 and made an instant hero.
The TSA is also being sued by Thomas Sawyer, a cancer survivor who was recently harassed and humiliated by TSA agents. Complaints over the TSA’s conduct are many—from the cancer survivor who was forced to remove her prosthetic breast and the seven year old boy who was strip searched at SLC international airport, to the pregnant mother who was harassed by TSA agents because she rightfully did not want her breast milk to go through the x-ray scanner.
The TSA’s polices intrude on our privacy and personal space. The government has given the TSA an enormous amount of power to which they are egregiously abusing. It is about time that TSA is held accountable for their blatantly reprehensible actions.





December 04, 2010 at 4:20 pm, Martha said:
I complained on both the TSA's website a year ago and directly to the Burbank Airport about the headaches I would get through the use of their pilot program using the full body scanner. A couple of weeks ago, I saw reported in the LA Times that the Burbank Airport and TSA both said there were no complaints re: the scanner. Unbelievable. Also, one time I went through that full-body scanner last year at Burbank Airport I was wearing a skirt. After the scanner, I had to get a pat down and the TSA agent said privately to me that she did not know why I was getting a pat down except that nearly all women who wore skirts through that machine also got a pat down. Again, unbelievable.
December 04, 2010 at 10:49 pm, Tom Sawyer said:
I am the Tom Sawyer that had the issue with the TSA patdown at Detroit Metro AIrport. I am neither suing anybody nor have I ever stated that was doing so. Your article is incorrect.
December 28, 2010 at 5:59 am, Tansiman said:
Tom,
I have some of the same type medical problems as you, My wife and I plan to fly to see my son next summer. Should I simply let them break my pouch and change it when I am in the plane? Or, do I have any “rights” of freedom of speech and not to be groped.
It may be simple, but everyone that I ask the question is timid with an answer , or beat around the issue.
December 12, 2010 at 2:10 am, Guest said:
Good luck to the two brave students!
I hope they win!
December 16, 2010 at 7:26 pm, gloomndoom said:
This is why no agency should ever have “enormous power.”
January 04, 2011 at 4:31 pm, James said:
Please win and put an end to this invasiveness, radiation exposure, and 4th ammendment violation. You guys are brave and great Americans! Thank you!!
God save the constitution.
June 17, 2012 at 8:14 pm, Interesting Links, December 2010 | An Eclectic Mind said:
[...] Harvard Law Students Sue TSA – “Two Harvard Law students recently filed suit against the Transportation Security Agency for their use of intrusive full-body scanners and enhanced pat down techniques.” Read more on DeathAndTaxes.com. I’m looking forward to seeing how this case goes. [...]