As a carnivore I can think of few things more satisfying than a delicious steak dinner complimented by a full-bodied bottle of red wine. And although I’m too young to be concerned with, or even bothered by, the distinct possibility of developing high cholesterol, the idea that red wine was good for me was reassuring. Given my frequent habit of devouring rib-eyes dripping with deliciousness, I figured downing a few too many glasses of Chianti would help wash away any pending heart disease.
Remember that famous study that said drinking red wine was good for your health? You know, the one that was featured on every news channel that you keep stored away in the memory bank whenever you feel like taking a bottle of Pinot Noir to the face? Well, as it turns out, the study’s results were comprised of utter bullshit. So that glass or two of red wine you’re having with dinner or before bed may be helping you tolerate life better, but there’s no evidence that proves it’s helping you live longer.
An extensive misconduct investigation that took three years to complete and produced a 60,000-page report, concludes that a researcher who has come to prominence in recent years for his investigations into the beneficial properties of resveratrol, a compound found in red wine, “is guilty of 145 counts of fabrication and falsification of data”.
In a statement published on the university’s news website on Wednesday, the University of Connecticut (UConn) Health Center said the investigation has led them to inform 11 scientific journals that had published studies conducted by Dr Dipak K. Das, a professor in the university’s Department of Surgery and director of its Cardiovascular Research Center.
The internal investigation, which covered seven years of work in Das’s lab, was triggered by an anonymous allegation of “research irregularities” in 2008.
This is probably one of the most strangely elaborate lies I’ve ever encountered. Dr. Das was found guilty of 145 counts of fabrication — that’s a lot of imaginary data. There aren’t many people out there who would go through the trouble of simply inventing an extensive report about the benefits of drinking red wine. Maybe it wasn’t about the fame, money or prestige of seeing his name on the nightly news and respected medical journals. Maybe he just was looking for a legitimate reason to drink more wine.
I guess sometimes we’re simply willing to believe the unbelievable if it means we’re allowed toss back a few more glasses when the in-laws show up uninvited for dinner.
[Medical News Today]
[Image via Shutterstock]





January 12, 2012 at 5:18 pm, Brittany said:
You can’t trust this story when you can’t even proof read the work.
January 12, 2012 at 9:46 pm, Mirabel said:
Only a loser comments on ” proof reading” rather than content.
January 12, 2012 at 10:14 pm, Cabernet82 said:
Matt’s one of the better writers on this site. I love his stories.
January 12, 2012 at 6:02 pm, Dalcione Reis Vollink said:
I think red wine is still good as a stress reliever. So maybe it still can help you live longer. I am going with that.
January 13, 2012 at 10:26 am, Slyski111 said:
I dunno – is it now bad for you then? So red wine is bad now, eggs are good now, milk is once again bad, air is good as long as you don’t live in LA now, orange juice is bad again, apple juice now has poison in it, soda has always been bad until next year when we hear that it’s actually good for us, running is really bad exercise, ellipticals are best, the sun is healthy between the hours of 3pm-4pm on wednesdays, breezes from the north are good for the immune system, but breezes from the south will kill you….
Come on people. Just live your lives. All this stuff is so effing ridiculous. New research comes out daily it seems about something we thought was bad that is now good and vice versa. Next thing bad will actually mean good and good will mean mediocre or subpar. It’s stupid and you’re all stupid for listening to it anyway.
January 13, 2012 at 1:48 pm, Ridiculous said:
Oh please, reductio ad absurdum. Alcohol is a poison, it will never be good for you. If someone wants the health benefits from red grapes…drink a glass of real grape juice.
January 13, 2012 at 1:37 pm, Goblinguru said:
The 60,000 page report was from the investigation, not the fraudulent doctor.
January 13, 2012 at 6:16 pm, wekkid23 said:
Fact Check-
” According to a report from the Associated Press (AP), Dr Nir Barzilai, whose team conducts resveratrol research at the Albert
Einstein College of Medicine in New York, says Das is not a major player in the field.
Barzilai told AP lots of labs around the world are conducting extensive
research into resveratrol, with encouraging results, and
the new allegation will not make a material difference.”
Resveratrol the chemical that is good for you in red wine is still being researched with “encouraging” results…but sulfites and alchohol are what mess you up in the long term.
February 16, 2012 at 4:48 am, John R Kingsley said:
Perhaps true that he falsified research, but does not negate the clinical facts of longevity and health in the French and other wine drinking populations. I would have to see the details of the report, for I suspect most of the research is true. Will continue to believe, and sample the wine. Love!
February 16, 2012 at 6:45 pm, Patricia Fultz said:
Hi John,
February 16, 2012 at 6:50 pm, Patricia Fultz said:
I read the original report of this misconduct case in a more reputable publication than D&T. The research in question was only marginal (and not reported in top journals) to the basic finding confirmed and reported by other researchers–that is, that resveratrol has beneficial health properties. So, drink up!
February 21, 2012 at 5:43 am, Patrick McDonald said:
So… we'll mayhaps be adding yet another medical miscreant to the Wall of Shame at the Nat'l Practitioner Data Bank.
If so, Das won't be lonely. The doctor-doo-bad fraternity consists – at mast count – of 237,000 doctors considered either "Dangerous" or "Questionable."
Just makes me proud to be an American.
September 20, 2012 at 2:15 am, Barbara Reddoch said:
"tolerating life better" is worth a lot!